PDA

View Full Version : Why don't guys talk?


Abashai
04-03-2008, 09:30 PM
Wow I hadn't logged on in such a long time that I had forgotten my username:embarrassed:.... how embarassing is that? I do have a valid excuse though.... on my computer at home it automatically logs on and I've been away from it so long that i've forgotten.

Anyway...

I have been thinking about this for a little while, and have talked with some friends, and in fact had a discussion just today with an older young person (31 and married, but hey its whats in the heart) about the fact that it seems like guys, generaly speaking (or maybe I've just been living in a box), just don't really talk with each other about anything more substantial than say... the latest sports results, or, with my group of friends, latest paintball equipment, hunting stuff, and other things that guys do.
Now I'm about to go on a bit of rant here so please be forewarned.

Why is it that girls are allowed to unburden their hearts to one another, and share their deepest feelings, what they are going through, different struggles that they have as young women, but as a guy it would seem to break "the unwritten Man Code" or being considered somewhat ,please excuse the expression, "gay"?
Wouldn't it be much more beneficial for young men if they were able to just find another guy that they connected with, a good pal, and just be able to share their struggles and just the different things they are facing?
Perhaps I am only speaking for myself, but I know that personally I have a difficult time just sitting down and talking, personally, to a friend. (you might not know by the ammount that I type) Perhaps part of it is just they way my personality was programed, but I think a large part of it has to do with the stereotypical "Man Code" that men generally try to take things on, by themselves, and don't really show that they are struggling. Which in a couple ways I would be able to see the plus side of it, because a man has to be the head of the home, and is placed in a leadership role, and has to, as the head of the home, really tackle by himself some serious issues. (I'm speaking completely hypothetical here, and only from a couple of my random observations about marriage.... those more experienced please correct me).
However this stereotypical image, can cause alot of the problems associated with the "coming of age" part of life. Or if not create the problems... help to accentuate them. By not talking about the things with others, you would sometimes be lead to think that you were the only one struggling these issues. (I'm being slightly vague because I don't have enough experience on this forum to know really what would be considered "Kosher").
Now arguably you could say that two young men who are struggling spiritually, perhaps would not be the best combination for a "heart to heart", perhaps alot of this is situation specific.
I do know from personal experience that there are demons, that are completely powerless once exposed. The devil, who is an opportunist, knows this and often attacks very personal areas where it would be a great embarassment to expose, and so by not exposing the demon gains power.
I think that if guys were a little more open with close friends there could be a reduction in "spiritual wavering" if I could say it like that.

And its not even neccisarily the sexual struggles that we young men have but the spiritual things, even when we have just reached a spiritual plateau, where you are not going backwards, but you aren't going forwards either. Many times you can just get contented in your spiritual walk where you think "everythings just alright" but really its not because your not comparing yourself to the standard that God's Word sets, you are comparing youself to the standards that you create, judging your spiritual position by the position of others. Just say "Well I'm doing alot better than they are so I must be doing alright". But what we fail to do is judge ourselves by God's Word, and the high standard that this Message sets. Just by talking and sharing with one another, it would not only help each other but even provoke each other to do better, to try harder, to fight harder.

And it ties in to something else that includes all young people in general, (if you are still reading this e-novel congratulations, and my appologies)

As a young man who has grown up in the Message, and has had friends surrounding me my whole life that have grown up in the Message... why is it that when we just get around together just hanging out, that it is so difficult to have a spiritually centered, and focused conversation? It seems like when young people get together (generalizing again) that the message is just something that is "understood" between them and it, most often, isn't the focal point of activities and conversation.
We get together just talk, joke, laugh, have fun, and all about things that aren't at all wrong, but just not based around the Word. It seems that the majority of the focus is on other things that don't really matter, and a small part is on things that are of utmost importance. It's completley backwards from what it should be... like I said not necisarily things that are wrong, but just things that take your time away from focusing on what is really important.

Please don't get the impression by reading this that I am some super spriritual, untouchable, perfect, young person that is critisizing everyone else. I am not by any stretch of the imagination. I am just trying to point out, and discuss things that I see in my own life that could probably use some changing. Anyone else? Or am I just the only one... the sore thumb... the stranger in the crowd?
Your insight would be really great.... just what do you think?

joris
04-04-2008, 06:48 AM
First of all, Abisai, thanks for posting this. I kinda understand what you're talking about alright.

I find this difficult myself.
In church, I have two friends. One is a guy, who I spend time together with when I'm at church meetings, and we've been together at some christian festivals. He's way more outgoing that I am (he talks easily), and it's fun. And -- well, it's fun mostly, conversations won't get real serious often.
I have another friend, who is a girl (I've had feelings for her, though she obviously didn't answer them) I respect here a lot, and at times share things on my heart (which is, faith/difficulties around contact with people, how to see God, how to grow there - though also sharing positive things)

Now... I've asked myself, why is it so natural to just have fun around this guy, and that. I don't really know.

Though part is, as you say, just culture; you're not used to it, and your friends aren't used to it.
There is no logic behind it, it's just that you never learned to do otherwise. Perhaps part of it is that, especially in our culture, sons don't talk to fathers (or not enough), which has to do with both son and father; well, if a father never shares (or responds to) such things, how is he going to do just that with his son? I don't mean to criticise any father here (it's more like realising this makes me long to pray for guidance there ;))
And, just to add that, another part is that men are just different from women, which is okay.

Though it's not okay never to talk about more serious things.
When I was going through an especially dark time of my life, there was one.. "friend". I hesitate to really call it like that, as I never really expressed what I was struggling with (I never shared to him, so I went through it -- alone)

JoeC
04-04-2008, 04:23 PM
It seems like when young people get together (generalizing again) that the message is just something that is "understood" between them...

Boom! Hit the nail on the head with that one, brother. It does amaze me that even at youth meetings, it can be hard to start up a conversation. Perhaps we take what we have for granted... or perhaps we fear people will see us as trying to be "superspiritual."

I find personally that intimate conversations happen in small group settings or one-on-one... usually in a coffee shop or some other relaxing setting. These conversations aren't simply changed from fun to serious like you change gears on a car... they're steered in the right direction with subtle intent and determined purpose.

I'll admit that sometimes I try to steer my conversations with certain friends that way and they're just not ready for it... we don't relate on that level. But ultimately, friendships are what we make of them, and the Guy Code is broken to begin with, so don't be afraid to break a broken code. :)

I hope that helps. Guy talk, anyone?

BroTrevor
04-04-2008, 04:50 PM
I guess I don't really see it too often with a big group of guys. But then, I doubt girls really express themselves in big groups either.

I have a few friends with whom I am able to hold deep life type conversations. I find spiritual, or deep conversations of any kind, happen usually in a smaller setting, among more trusted friends.

I think we've all said something in a crowd once, and then been ridiculed for it. That I think stops us from ever making that mistake again, and so we learn early not to say serious deep stuff that is important to you, in a big group where you might be ridiculed.

So, I recommend, find a good buddy...and just start talking. Steer the conversation as JoeC said. Maybe some of your friends aren't comfy with that. They're probably from Minnesota and their grandparents are lutheran.

Come on by sometime man. I'll talk deep. I'm not afraid!

Jezz
04-04-2008, 06:55 PM
I really only talk to two guys in my life about the deep things in life: my dad and my friend Dave. Its only recently that me and Dave started to open up about more personal and spiritual things. We're currently trying to get a youth bible study group up and going but we've got to wait on what our pastor says about it first.

In a group setting we used to never talk about the Lord, its still quite rare now but it does happen occasionally. If you want to change the behaviour of the young people in your church pray about it and provide a good example. You can't force Godly conversation on them.

After church all the men gather to talk about what our pastor preached on and for a long time none of the young guys who were coming of age stood with them. When I started standing with the men I did it all by myself but it wasn't long before some of my friends started doing it also. Sometimes you just need somebody to do the right thing and not be afraid of the ridicule they might receive.

One of my favourite scriptures is 1 Timothy 4:12: Let no man despise thy youth; but be thou an example of the believers, in word, in conversation, in faith, in spirit, in love, in purity. Its always spoken to me of the life young people should live.

Abashai
04-05-2008, 06:53 PM
Thanks for the response, it was good. I guess whats needed first is to establish a really good friendship with someone, and then you can start the one on one.

I was also receiving some private messages from some ladies exploring forbidden territory, and was just wondering if it would be permitted to double post this on the main forum? Or perhaps the friendships forum? Since I'm very new I'm not too sure what's what around here. Originally I had just wanted some guy feedback but then thought about it and perhaps they might have some more insight from another perspective.

HotShot53
04-05-2008, 10:22 PM
I was also receiving some private messages from some ladies exploring forbidden territory, and was just wondering if it would be permitted to double post this on the main forum? Or perhaps the friendships forum? Since I'm very new I'm not too sure what's what around here. Originally I had just wanted some guy feedback but then thought about it and perhaps they might have some more insight from another perspective.

It's your topic, you are welcome to post it again in a section the girls can comment on publicly... and don't worry, we give warnings at least once or twice before we get upset at anything ;)

BroTrevor
04-07-2008, 12:51 PM
I was also receiving some private messages from some ladies exploring forbidden territory,

Private messages on the forum?

Forbidden territory?

I trust these messages were decent, clean, above the bar, good, ok, and all the rest.

If not, let me know...we don't want anything "forbidden" taking place here.

Abashai
04-07-2008, 06:39 PM
Ha:)
Everything was kosher... I was just kind of refering to the girls "infiltrating the fort", but then I forgot that our security has already been compromised and thats why we had that other crazy topic where everyone was talking in code.:ninja: